Beyond Joint Forest Management: Dugli-Jawarra People's Protected Area
This brief case study, part of the larger United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) publication "In Search of Excellence: Exemplary Forest Management in Asia and the Pacific", begins by noting that sustaining the incomes of forest communities while conserving biodiversity can be a challenge. As Biswa Ranjan Phukan reports here, however, a new approach to forest management in India is being implemented to try to change the attitude of economically poor people who might have otherwise dismissed conservation - and eschewed related behaviours - as a threat to their lifestyles and source of financial stability.
Phukan explains that, while the local government owns the Dugli-Jawarra forest area in Chhattisgarh state, villagers living nearby are entitled to collect non-timber forest products (NTFPs). For many years, a lack of clear ownership rights meant that villagers had no incentive to manage the forest resources, and illegal harvesting was widespread. The forest was becoming severely degraded due to excessive cutting of trees for timber and the collection of other forest products. In the late 1980s, Indian forestry policy was adapted in an effort to address this degradation. State governments were asked to encourage local people to participate in forest conservation. As part of this process, in the mid-1990s 11 Joint Forest Management (JFM) committees were established in Dugli-Jawarra, leading to the creation of a People's Protected Area (PPA) in the forest. These JFM committees now make decisions about the PPA.
Broad participation of several different social groups is a central strategy driving the JFM committees' actions. The people involved with the management of Dugli-Jawarra forest come from forest-dependent communities and villages, the state forest department, timber and NFTP traders, pharmaceutical industries, and other local communities. Each of these stakeholders has different objectives, motivations, and strategies impacting their perspective on the forest and what benefits it might bring them. However, according to Phukan, the groups appear to work together effectively. Part of the reason, he suggests, is that the state forest department and forest-dependent people share forest management responsibilities, such as control of forest fires and soil erosion, silviculture (the science of growing forest trees), identification and conservation of medicinal plants, and sustainable harvesting of NTFPs. These groups also share the responsibility of developing village resources, as well as the financial benefits accruing from the forest.
In fact, the author suggests that the main thrust of the Dugli-Jawarra's PPA saw villagers and the forest department working together to adopt management strategies based on local community participation and empowerment, including:
- income generation opportunities through skill development
- awareness campaigns
- lectures on biodiversity conservation
- promotion of non-destructive harvesting
- equitable sharing of benefits from the managed forests
- engagement in various village development activities.
Furthermore, research shows that:
- Villagers have learned new management skills, such as participatory forest protection, silviculture, how to sustainably harvest forest products, and primary processing of NTFPs
- The improved infrastructure in the PPA helps villagers trade their products
- Improved skills and market access allows villagers to sell directly to consumers, rather than through a middleman, meaning they get better prices for their products
- Villagers are now more likely to make decisions as a group, rather than acting for individual gains
- The JFM system has empowered villagers to discuss needs and aspirations with forest officials
- The new forest policies have rehabilitated the Dugli-Jawarra forests. The policies have encouraged a shift in the approach from forest management for timber production to a multiple use framework focusing on NTFPs and poverty alleviation of forest-dependent communities.
What types of communication approaches have contributed to these positive impacts? According to Phukan, part of the equation is a democratic, participatory structure guiding the decision-making process for Forest Protection Committees (FPCs) and Village Forest Committees (VFCs). Every member apparently has equal opportunity to express his or her opinion, and the final decision is made by majority decision. The presence of 50% of the members of the executive committee and 30% of the general committee is required to reach a quorum. This spirit of full, fair participation is also reflected in the fact that each family belonging to the committee receives an allowance of forest products.
Phukan indicates that the involvement of those in positions of power in communicating kudos - positive reinforcement - for good work may also be a strong motivator for continued behaviour change: "The visit of several high-profile dignitaries to the Dugli-Jawarra sal forests has been a major source of inspiration for staff of the forest department and the village communities. A member of Dugli FPC smiled, 'Rajivji (late Rajiv Gandhi, then Prime Minister of India) came to our village in 1985. He spoke to us, he asked about our problems...Afterwards, I was strongly motivated to do something to help my community.' Visits of top officials from the state government such as the Secretary, Commissioner, and Principal Chief Conservator of Forests are always a source of encouragement and inspiration. The villagers, as well as forest department staff, appreciate the plaudits they are given for outstanding work."
Despite evidence that strategies explored to date have been fruitful, Phukan notes that further challenges remain. To cite only one example: "Despite the good relations between the forest department and village committees, the forest department still has the right to dissolve local committees at any time. This maintains an imbalance of power."
Editor's note: this paper is one case study included within In Search of Excellence: Exemplary Forest Management in Asia and the Pacific", edited by Patrick B. Durst, Chris Brown, Henrylito D. Tacio & Miyuki Ishikawa. United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), 2005.
"Working Together to Protect Forests in India", id21, July 28 2005 - featured in id21News Number 168, August 2005 (click here for the archives).
- Log in to post comments











































