Development action with informed and engaged societies
After nearly 28 years, The Communication Initiative (The CI) Global is entering a new chapter. Following a period of transition, the global website has been transferred to the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits) in South Africa, where it will be administered by the Social and Behaviour Change Communication Division. Wits' commitment to social change and justice makes it a trusted steward for The CI's legacy and future.
 
Co-founder Victoria Martin is pleased to see this work continue under Wits' leadership. Victoria knows that co-founder Warren Feek (1953–2024) would have felt deep pride in The CI Global's Africa-led direction.
 
We honour the team and partners who sustained The CI for decades. Meanwhile, La Iniciativa de Comunicación (CILA) continues independently at lainiciativadecomunicacion.com and is linked with The CI Global site.
Time to read
4 minutes
Read so far

Modelling Cross-Gender and Sexual Relations: Exploring the Soul Buddyz Edutainment Initiative in South Africa

0 comments
Date
Summary

This paper explores the representations of "positive" cross-gender relations, as well as associated constructs, in the Soul Buddyz edutainment initiative, which is primarily geared towards 8-12 year-olds, and intended to provide "positive" role models for girls and boys. The broad goals of this paper were to: raise questions in reference to HIV/AIDS prevention initiatives dealing with cross-gender relations and associated constructs, spark critical reflection upon these issues being considered as crucial within the context of the HIV/AIDS epidemic, and potentially strengthen prevention initiatives.

The paper reports that HIV/AIDS among youth is a serious problem in South Africa. Cross-gender relations and associated constructs surrounding masculinity/femininity and sexuality are increasingly recognised as being at the heart of the issue. For instance, gender norms for girls may entail pressure to have a boyfriend, demonstrate sexual ignorance and passivity, and be submissive. Intimate cross-gender relations may be characterised by violence, inequality, non-communication about sex, and pressure to engage in unsafe sexual behaviour. Growing attention has thus been given to developing initiatives geared towards children and very young adolescents (VYAs), intended to address attitudes and behaviours surrounding gender and sexuality.

According to the paper, the edutainment strategy has received increasing recognition in the communication, health, and development fields, in terms of achieving behavioural and social change. The "power" of edutainment is described as stemming from its ability to rouse emotions, role-model "positive" attitudes and behaviours, bring taboo topics like HIV/AIDS and sexuality into the public eye, stimulate discussion, and illustrate the consequences of healthy and unhealthy behaviour. Three behavioural models may be found within an edutainment drama: "positive" models demonstrating beneficial lifestyles; "negative" models portraying detrimental views and lifestyles; and "transitional" models, i.e., characters who are shown "transforming their lives by moving from uncertainty or discarding adverse styles of behaviour in favour of beneficial ones." The Soul City Institute developed the Soul Buddyz programme "to improve the quality of life of young South Africans through improved health literacy." This included television, radio, and print materials.

Reflecting on the analysis of the material, the author makes the following observations:

  • Sympathetic "Positive" Boys and Powerful "Positive" Girls - The character All Star is presented as reactive towards and respectful of girls, learning the importance of communicating with one's partner and understanding that one does not have to have sex in order to be a man. The paper explains that in effect, ideas surrounding masculinity/femininity, rather than individuals themselves, may be at the root of the problem, as was the case in All Star and Zandi's story. Rather than presenting boys and men as obstructions, accounting for their ability to adopt constructive attitudes may increase chances of improving cross-gender relations. Zandi, in turn, by being presented as able to make her own choices, is effectively portrayed as powerful. In a way, such a depiction is important because strong social investments in having a boyfriend, achieving love, and avoiding rejection may constrain the ability of some girls to be assertive about what they themselves want. The author notes, however, that Zandi does not face much opposition from her boyfriend. In addition to portraying powerful female role models, there may be a need for models who meet resistance to what they want but still manage to power through. Having both models may allow for a more holistic representation of the kinds of relationships girls may find themselves in and may demonstrate different ways of dealing with adversity.
  • Polarisation - Presenting some form of common ground between boys and girls, as in the case of All Star and Zandi, may be worthwhile. Though ideas surrounding masculinity and femininity in patriarchal societies are often upheld in opposition to each other, addressing this understanding may be integral to strengthening HIV/AIDS initiatives intended to challenge gender constructs. Promoting cross-gender friendships, moreover, as found in the makeup and dynamics of the Soul Buddyz group as a whole, could not only help to undermine the polarisation of masculinity and femininity but also serve as a basis for greater mutual respect in intimate cross-gender relationships. In effect, "sex and HIV/AIDS education must raise possibilities of boys and girls relating to each other not as stereotypical opposites, but as potential equals and friends."
  • Overemphasising Youth Sexuality as a Process of Becoming - In the considered Soul Buddyz material, particularly that concerning puberty, youth characters are effectively constructed as needing advice in order to solve their problems. In particular, they are presented as in need of adult advice, since that from their peers may misguide them. The paper proposes that caution needs to be exerted in this respect. For, to construct adults as "right" and youth (and by extension, children and VYAs) as "wrong" arguably implies that the latter will "become" right as they get older, rather than "being" right at the present time. Thus, considering children, VYAs, and youth as in need of (adult) advice could potentially devalue what they have to say now. Though, as one of the factors contributing to HIV/AIDS risk behaviour is a lack of intergenerational communication surrounding sex, presenting trusted adults as the "go-to" source for information may have its merits. There may thus be a need for a portrayal that is more nuanced than presenting either adults or children/VYAs/youth as being wrong or right. Rather, emphasising intergenerational communication in and of itself may be more worthwhile.
  • Other Reflections on Youth Sexuality: Accounting for Pleasure in Addition to Danger, and Multiple Forms of Sexuality - In the Soul Buddyz material, there is considerable emphasis placed on the consequences and dangers, particularly pregnancy, of having sex if "too young", largely illustrated through the charter Tammy's experience and her being "so scared". Though it is arguably important in an initiative geared towards 8-12 year-olds to outline the consequences of having sex so as to illustrate what this age group may not be aware of, emphasising pregnancy as a consequence is problematic. It may contribute to an understanding of sex as more dangerous for girls, thereby exacerbating the aforementioned construct of them as sexual gatekeepers and also increasing the chances of boys engaging in unprotected sexual intercourse, as they are not the ones at risk of becoming pregnant. Overemphasising pregnancy could also potentially lead to youth experimenting with other forms of sexual engagement, such as anal sex, for which there might be the presumption that since there is no risk of pregnancy, the sex is not "unsafe". Something to consider may be offering a more detailed account of the risks of other sexually transmitted infections (STIs) in addition to HIV/AIDS, at the same time as not overemphasising the risk of pregnancy.
  • Accounting for the Sexual Rights of Children and VYAs - According to the paper, one's sexual rights go beyond the right to information, services, and protection, extending to (i) the right for individual sexual practice to be pleasurable, (ii) non-discrimination, and (iii) the freedom of individual sexual expression. Advocacy for children's sexual rights that goes beyond the right to protection from sexual abuse and HIV/AIDS to also account for the right to express sexual desire has therefore often been muted. Valuing children and VYAs as both beings and becomings requires an acknowledgement of them as holders of sexual rights.

The paper concludes that the majority of the points raised pertain to the development of a more nuanced understanding of both gender and sexuality in the form of a continuum rather than a binary format. The way in which gender and sexuality are contextualised matters. Continuum rather than binary conceptualisations may allow for a more holistic understanding of the complexities surrounding gender and sexuality, which, given the nature of the HIV/AIDS epidemic, is crucial. Serious attention needs to be given to how the above issues are conceptualised within HIV/AIDS prevention initiatives, as such understandings have considerable implications for practice and lived realities.