Development action with informed and engaged societies
After nearly 28 years, The Communication Initiative (The CI) Global is entering a new chapter. Following a period of transition, the global website has been transferred to the University of the Witwatersrand (Wits) in South Africa, where it will be administered by the Social and Behaviour Change Communication Division. Wits' commitment to social change and justice makes it a trusted steward for The CI's legacy and future.
 
Co-founder Victoria Martin is pleased to see this work continue under Wits' leadership. Victoria knows that co-founder Warren Feek (1953–2024) would have felt deep pride in The CI Global's Africa-led direction.
 
We honour the team and partners who sustained The CI for decades. Meanwhile, La Iniciativa de Comunicación (CILA) continues independently at lainiciativadecomunicacion.com and is linked with The CI Global site.
Time to read
4 minutes
Read so far

Prevention with Positives (PWP): Does It Work?

0 comments
Date
Summary

"Show me an anti-stigma program that works consistently and reliably across a range of settings, age and gender groups, across various religious, cultural and economic settings, and I’ll show you the unicorn I have in my back yard."

The above is one element of this critique of an approach to addressing the core route of HIV transmission called prevention with positives (PWP), which involves identifying those living with HIV and focusing prevention efforts upon these people (thereby reducing the risk of HIV transmission to uninfected sex partners and needle-sharing partners).

The authors point to the following perceived problems with PWP, particularly in the developing country context (The focus below is on communication elements of these problems.):

  1. It is difficult to accurately identify those living with HIV, and who is causing the bulk of HIV transmission, and why. "The fly in the ointment is that the highest viral load is found in people testing HIV-negative, in the Window Period....In other words, more-or-less half of all new infections are caused by people who test HIV-negative using the standard Rapid Test." Patient and Orr challenge the contention by some that post-test counseling includes information about refraining from unprotected sex if the person tests HIV-negative (e.g., that person could actually transmit HIV - he or she could have HIV, even though they test HIV-antibody negative). The authors do concede, however, that this first problem could be addressed through education, training, and allocation of resources.
  2. Programme designers (and funders) fallaciously believe that it is possible to effectively focus prevention efforts on the individual living with HIV, ignoring or working around the context in which that person lives: their partners, family, and their social environment. Stigma is one element of this issue, according to Patient and Orr. "When you ask people what they mean by stigma, it boils down to the fear of being viewed differently (attitudes) or treated differently (actively discriminated against) in a negative sense, by people they know, interact with, or seek acceptance from. Here's the kicker: Our (PWP) response is to tell people living with HIV that they - and they alone - need to separately congregate as a special group (with great secrecy, called confidentiality) and learn a whole bunch of new (different) behaviors such as nutrition for people living with HIV, treatment literacy, how to take measures to protect partners, babies and other people, all of which will make them appear and act differently to everyone else. Then we expect them to go home and display these different behaviors. Do you see the problem?....As the phenomenon of stigma shows, what people want (including emotional needs such as belonging and acceptance) can very often be stronger than what we think they really need. Many people are truly more afraid of being alone and isolated than they are afraid of illness and death."

Patient and Orr provide a case study from their own experience to illuminate the second problem, stressing that their point is not that we shouldn't make efforts to ensure that people living with HIV access care and support in a more efficient manner (e.g., special waiting areas, files with special stickers). In November 2009, the authors drew upon the concept of Post Test Clubs (PTCs) - developed in Uganda, early 1990s in an effort to encourage people to get tested - which originally was strictly an advocacy programme where a group of people who had been tested for HIV shared their experiences of having been tested for HIV, whether the outcome was positive or negative. The purpose of the original PTC process was simply to encourage others to come forward and get tested. Other subsequent versions of PTC included income-generation projects. Patient and Orr modified the basic PTC concept because they felt that it did not really address the underlying motivation to get tested strongly enough, especially for people who did not perceive themselves at risk. Also, it did not address the question of what to do after the HIV test.

So, in North West Province and then Southern Free State (South Africa), they first met with groups and individuals in the communities they hoped to reach - church groups, schools, youth groups, home-based care workers, amongst others - and asked them to discuss their community's primary challenges, in order of priority. (The only criteria for joining the PTC was to provide written evidence (from a health centre) that the person had been tested for HIV and diabetes (glucose test) and had their blood pressure checked. Results were not asked for or discussed.) Patient and Orr then merged these lists of priorities and set about designing self-help interventions to address each of these needs. Next, they embedded - directly or indirectly - HIV prevention and treatment information and methods, such as indicating which foods were of special importance to people living with HIV and tuberculosis (TB) within the context of a balanced diet or explaining HIV transmission within the context of general germ theory, the terminology of medical treatment, how the immune system works, and lifestyle diseases such diabetes and hypertension.

If the person assessed was competent, they were permitted to teach-forward that session. Dissemination of information and skills was primarily within intimate networks: Friends taught friends and family, and family taught family and neighbours. In an 11-month period, 34,093 activities and sessions were delivered within a community of 135,000 people, starting with 75 volunteer facilitators. Of these activities, 16,544 were HIV-related (prevention and treatment) and 2,068 people tested for HIV, "without much effort....What we learned was that if we taught everyone the same information - regardless as to their HIV status - about things that they were really interested in, issues such as HIV-related stigma did not arise as a barrier. What we did not anticipate occurred about 6 months into the process, when people started to disclose their HIV status to their fellow club members. Without exception, there was not one negative response reported."

As a result of the outcomes of the PTC process, Patient and Orr were asked to carry out a PWP-focused support group process in the North West Province. In short, they found that, when community activities were reduced, "it became pretty obvious to the community that program sessions were being attended only by HIV-positive individuals....Even when door-to-door recruitment was increased by more than 400%, this did not resolve the problem: The perception of the program had been changed from being a Wellness program to an HIV (PWP) program, and fear of stigma closed the doors for many to attend."

"The point is that PWP has significant challenges as a stand-alone process, but is far more accepted when presented as only one aspect of a larger and broader community Wellness program."

Source

Email from David Patient to The Communication Initiative on January 3 2014. Image credit: HIV Prevention with Positives (PWP) website