Overcoming Resistance to COVID-19 Vaccine Adoption: How Affective Dispositions Shape Views of Science and Medicine

Philip Merrill College of Journalism, University of Maryland (Newhagen); College of Media and Communication, Texas Tech University (Bucy)
"While the thrust of this article has to do with vaccine adoption, these results hint at a nuanced understanding of fringe group coincidence that begins with a common embrace of misinformation and conspiracy to fuel movement growth and goes beyond simple categorizations based on political ideology and demographics."
Public health experts in the United States (US) have recognised that resistance on the part of some to a COVID-19 vaccine, when it becomes widely available, could thwart the effort to stem the pandemic. Concern has largely focused on anti-vaccine protestors, who captured headlines in the early days of the pandemic (April and May 2020). However, the picture is more complex. This article draws on the results of two surveys tapping into social and political attitudes in the US, featuring questions asking respondents to rate their trust in fact-based processes and their feelings toward polarising social groups and institutions. In essence, the analysis exposes a challenge facing the public health community in the lead-up to the approval of a vaccine: how to craft messages that will speak to a set of disparate groups, each of which harbours a unique set of biases when processing COVID-19-vaccine-related information.
The surveys on which the study is based are as follows: The first, which probed attitudes toward risk of the novel coronavirus, included data from the US (N = 700) collected on March 19 2020, at the height of the pandemic's first wave (Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication at the University of Cambridge, 2020). The second, which was conducted just before the 2018 midterm US congressional elections, included data from 3,000 Americans (American National Election Study (ANES), 2018).
Selected findings from a look at combined data from these surveys include:
- Politically conservative survey respondents appear more likely to align themselves with the anti-vax movement, which is frequently characterised by opposition to public health expert advice, whereas politically liberal respondents place more trust in science and medicine but express some doubt about vaccinating and might be described as hesitant.
- However, ideology does not fully explain vaccine resistance. Trust in science is lower for those who say they will not get a vaccine than those who say they will, regardless of ideological orientation. Factor analysis of anti-vaxxer trust scores shows some commonalities among liberal and conservative skeptics. In particular, those who would reject the COVID-19 vaccine display a high level of distrust for dissimilar social groups (immigrants and people who speak other languages - "others"), not unlike the populist attitudes that drive support for US President (conservative) Donald Trump. This is important, say the researchers, because it shows that anti-vax attitudes are connected to other fringe groups that embrace misinformation and conspiracy.
- Analysis of affective assessments of polarising groups and individuals suggests that those planning to refuse vaccination can be described as having differing ways of engaging with issues: One group fits the mold of the anti-vax movement, where misinformation and conspiracy trump mainstream science and medicine. The other group is more apt to accept science but may be hesitant to adopt a vaccine in its early stages of development because they feel the vaccine's development is being rushed and may not be safe or effective.
- Taken together, the findings suggest that emotion plays an important role in the processing of misinformation and conspiracy. At a basic emotional level, various groups appear to be driven by anger and fear, which manifest themselves in virus-related behaviours that are driven by denial and alarm. The researchers note: "These responses occur within an increasingly distorted and fractured media ecology characterized by hyper-polarization, where preferred information channels act as preprocessing filters to organize information into ideologically familiar frames."
Thus, the idea is that the model of information reception implied by the growing divide in vaccination attitudes is one of emotional disposition rather than rational deliberation, where the two key affective orientations to the pandemic are denial and alarm. Denialists, who tend to support President Trump, rely on false or misleading information as the foundation for their worldview. This group generally distrusts and has colder emotional feelings toward outside groups (the "other"). Alarmists, on the other hand, rely on fact-based information and take rational action, but pay such close attention to public affairs that they may routinely experience fear in response.
One implication of these findings is that traditional, information-based public service announcements (PSAs) or similar appeals may be unlikely to be effective in reaching everyone who says they will not vaccinate against COVID-19. Rather, a more nuanced communication approach is required - particularly in light of this study's uncovering of dissonant groups with unique agendas grounded in the same baseline distrust for information coming from professionals such as doctors, scientists, or journalists.
The Harvard Kennedy School (HKS) Misinformation Review, 1(6). Image credit: Freepix
Comments
Facts and Trust - COVID Vaccine Communication
Interesting, but vague. First we need to be sure we actually have the facts, then figure out what makes them important to multiple groups. Trust in government is perhaps at an all-time low, economic fears battle with fears of illness. Corporations seem to be attempting to replace government, yet their interests are profit, not benefiting society.
Sally











































